The first newsroom I worked in had a reporter whose entire beat was a single county courthouse. He had been sitting in the same wooden chair at the back of the same hearing room for close to two decades. The judges knew his name. The clerks knew his coffee order. When a local councilman got indicted, it was not because some national wire service parachuted in. It was because that reporter had been watching the paper trail for years, and he finally had the pieces. I think about him a lot when I read Silicon Valley companies talking about "connecting people" and "building community."
The companies have the better slogans. The newspaper had the better habits.
What "community" meant in a newsroom
In a newsroom, community showed up in the daily work. Obituaries went in because someone at the paper believed that the death of a retired schoolteacher in a small town mattered enough to print. Classifieds ran because a used sofa and a job at a hardware store and an apartment over a storefront were all part of how a place works. The paper printed school board agendas, little league results, library schedules, and the full list of names at the senior center pancake breakfast.
The civic value of that work could not be measured only by the money each column-inch earned. A paper had a seat at the table in the place where it was printed, and obligations came with it. The business and the civic presence depended on a continuing relationship with the same people.
Treating "community" as a marketing layer on a product with no particular geography loses that obligation. A social network can connect people after a factory closes. A newsroom can keep asking what happens to the town, who is responsible, and what its residents need next.
Accountability had a face
I can name the editor who would have killed a bad story I filed in 1998. I can name the publisher whose name was on the masthead. I can name the ombudsman, back when papers still had one, whose job was to hear complaints from readers and write about them in the paper itself, in public, under his own name.
That structure was often slow, stubborn, and limited by the prejudices of the people in the chairs. But the people in the chairs had names. They lived somewhere. They ate at the diner down the street from the office. If they got the story wrong, the mayor could call them. If the coverage of a minority neighborhood was thin, an organizer could walk in the front door and ask why.
Global reach gives a platform none of that local presence. A content policy written in Mountain View cannot be argued with at the diner. A trust-and-safety team in another time zone does not bump into the high school principal. When a reader can reach only a help center form, even finding someone responsible becomes work.
Civic muscle is not the same as reach
Discussions about "the death of newspapers" often measure what is lost in circulation or audience. Those figures do not tell us whether anyone is still watching the courthouse.
The Philadelphia Inquirer's "Disorder in the Court" series exposed failures of justice in the city's courts and led to federal and state investigations. Civic muscle is also what happened when a mid-market paper ran a series on predatory lending and the state legislature passed a law. It is what happened when the local weekly reported on a zoning scheme and the scheme fell apart.
Many local papers were too close to the powerful, too quiet on race, too cheap with their reporters, too slow to cover people they did not already know. The civic muscle I am describing was unevenly applied. Even with those failures, there were people in a building whose job was to keep watching a place and demanding answers. The ability to distribute a story around the world is useful. It cannot substitute for the work that produces one.
Serving a place on the web
The Knight Commission's report last year, Informing Communities, starts with people's information needs rather than the survival of a particular news business. It considers journalism alongside libraries, public institutions and other local sources. Its recommendation for a community information hub does not mean one website gathering everything. Connecting people to information held elsewhere is part of the proposal.1 I find that a productive question for a local site: what does someone here need to know, and where can we help them find it?
Suppose a local newspaper publishes a good story about cuts to the library budget. It explains the competing proposals, questions the figures and tells readers who will make the decision. A parent reading it may still have a question: will our branch be open when I can take the children? The reporting should help the parent understand the dispute; the website should also help them plan the visit.
Adrian Holovaty described how this worked at LJWorld. Weather forecasts had been stored with temperatures and conditions in separate fields. When the site made pages for little-league games, it could show the forecasts beside the games. The additional value came from putting information where a reader needed it.2 A forecast would not tell a parent whether a game had been canceled; that decision would still need a source.
A page offering the library's opening hours makes a continuing promise. Before adding it, I would want to know where its information comes from, who checks it and how a reader can report a mistake. A visible date helps, but does not keep the page current. An automatic import still needs a dependable source and someone responsible for noticing when it fails.
Sometimes the better choice is a link. If the library maintains a clear, current schedule, send readers directly to branch hours rather than to a home page where they must begin another search. I'd rather help someone get an answer than give them a longer route to it under our own masthead.
If residents cannot find out which branches a proposed cut would affect, that gap deserves a question to the people making the proposal. Reporting may be needed to establish what the schedule ought to say, whose needs the decision overlooks, or why the information is unavailable. A useful website can help expose the problem and give residents a way to press for an answer.
An older story should retain its date and historical meaning. Someone arriving through search may be reading a report from before the decision was made. A clearly dated update or a link to later coverage can help the reader find what happened next without rewriting the earlier account as though the outcome had always been known.
What a technology company could borrow
A technology company that wanted to take the newspaper model seriously would not need to buy a printing press. It would need to staff for obligation to place. That means local people hired with local context. It means putting a fraction of product decisions into the hands of people who live where the product is used. It means naming the editor. It means publishing a correction page. It means sending a person to a zoning hearing on a Tuesday night because that is the job, not because it maps to a quarterly metric.
Start with a recurring local question and give someone the responsibility to answer it well. The library example joins reporting, product design and upkeep around one parent's need. The staff and attention that make it work have a cost. A thing can be valuable and important without scaling past a place.
The part the Valley keeps missing
I have worked in both industries long enough to stop being sentimental about either one. Newspapers made plenty of bad decisions, including many of the ones that made them vulnerable to displacement. I am not arguing that the Valley should have spared them. I am arguing that the Valley did not bother to copy the good parts before deciding the whole category was obsolete.
When the industry treats "community" as a word you print on a pitch deck, the word goes thin. When it treats community as a standing obligation to a real place with real names, the word holds weight. The courthouse reporter I mentioned at the top could not have told you his company's mission statement. He knew the name of every assistant prosecutor in the building. That was the mission statement. It is still, I think, the better one.
Footnotes
-
Knight Commission on the Information Needs of Communities in a Democracy, Informing Communities: Sustaining Democracy in the Digital Age (2009), Part I and Recommendation 15. ↩
-
Adrian Holovaty, "A fundamental way newspaper sites need to change", September 6, 2006. ↩